2011                                                                                              
James Pope (Gainesville, FL)
Missouri Valley College

Kyle Martin (Mt. Vernon, IL) 
Greenville College

2009                                                                                              
Brian Gamber (Mt. Vernon, IL)
Taylor University - NAIA DII

Josh Davis (Evansville, IN) 
Columbia College (MO) - NAIA DI

Travis Thurau (Sparta, IL)

Southwestern College (KS) - NAIA

C.J. Trotter (Hopkinsville, KY)

University of Southern Indiana - NCAA DII

Stelios Tzoutzis (Athens, GR)

Mansfield University (PA) - NCAA DII

2008                                                                                               
Andrae Spraggins (formerly Andre Morris) (St. Louis, MO)
Columbia College (MO) - NAIA DI

Darren Best (Melbourne, Australia)
York College - NAIA

Jamal Herriott (Pensacola, FL)

William Woods University - NAIA

2007                                                                                               
Tommy Holder (Carbondale, IL)
Southern Illinois University Carbondale - NCAA DI

Nathan Owen (Crofton, KY)
University of Nebraska Omaha - NCAA DII